Best Overall: the BLACK+DECKER TO1313SBD 4-slice toaster oven. It fits a 9-inch pizza or four slices of bread in a 14.5-inch-wide body, pulls a 4.3 average across more than 22,000 reviews, and sits comfortably inside a sub-100 dollar budget with room to spare. That combination of proven reliability and compact footprint is why it heads this roundup of the best toaster ovens under 100 dollars for 2026.
We spent six weeks with eight countertop ovens on our own counter, toasting the same bread, reheating the same frozen pizza and baking the same tray of cookies in each one. Every model here costs less than a hundred dollars, and every one of them does at least two things well: toast, and heat a real meal. The differences show up in slice count, whether convection is a real fan or just a marketing word, and how hot the outside of the box gets while it works.
If you want the wider picture first, our guide to the best toaster ovens overall covers what you gain when you move past the sub-100 tier. If your priority is crunch rather than capacity, our picks for the best air fryer toaster ovens focus on mesh baskets and fan-driven browning.
Two numbers frame everything that follows. Slice capacity is the honest one: a 4-slice oven toasts four slices of bread at once, a 6-slice oven toasts six, and a 2-slice oven toasts two no matter what the box claims. Wattage is the one buyers misread most often. Higher wattage means faster heat recovery and stronger browning, but a 1150W oven at 4.3 stars and 22,000 reviews will beat an 1800W oven at 4.2 stars every time you pick it up.
Table of Contents
Top 3 Best Toaster Ovens Under $100 in October
BLACK+DECKER TO1313SBD
- 9-inch pizza or 4 slices
- 4 cooking functions
- 30-minute timer with stay-on
Every Pick at a Glance in 2026
Slice count, dish fit, wattage and door type for all eight models, so you can rule out half the list before you read a single review.
| Product | Specs | Action |
|---|---|---|
| BLACK+DECKER TO1313SBD |
|
Check Latest Price |
| Hamilton Beach Easy Reach 6-Slice |
|
Check Latest Price |
| Cuisinart TOB-40 1800W |
|
Check Latest Price |
 BLACK+DECKER 5-in-1 Air Fry Oven |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Hamilton Beach Sure-Crisp Combo |
|
Check Latest Price |
 BLACK+DECKER TO1760SS Convection |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Elite Gourmet ETO490 9L |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Elite Gourmet ETO236 2-Slice |
|
Check Latest Price |
1. BLACK+DECKER TO1313SBD 4-Slice Toaster Oven – Best Overall
BLACK+DECKER TO1313SBD Toaster Oven, 15.47 Inch, Silver
1150W
10 liter cavity
14.5 in wide
450F max
Bake, broil, toast, keep warm
Pros
- Fits a 9-inch pizza or 4 slices in a 14.5-inch-wide body
- Over 22000 reviews with a 4.3 average
- Slide-out crumb tray and stay-on timer
- Natural convection airflow without a fan
Cons
- Outer surfaces run hot enough to need oven mitts
- Convection results need a full 10-minute preheat
This is the oven we kept reaching for. The curved interior is the reason it toasts four slices of standard bread with room at the corners, which a square 4-slice cavity usually does not. Across six weeks of weekday breakfasts, it never gave us a batch with two pale slices and two dark ones.
The controls are three knobs: temperature, function and a 30-minute timer with a stay-on position. The oven will not heat unless the timer is set, which is a small safety habit that also stops the elements running indefinitely. It is a design we have seen hold up for years, and owners on r/Cooking repeatedly describe budget BLACK+DECKER models lasting years in dorms, motorhomes and first apartments.
The honest weakness is heat. The thin steel walls mean the top and sides get hot during use, and reviewers consistently say to treat it like a stovetop with mitts on. That is normal for this class of oven, not a defect, but it matters if you plan to park a wooden board or a plastic container next to it.
The second thing to plan for is preheat. For toast, a few minutes is enough. For convection baking, owners report that giving it the full ten minutes is the difference between even browning and a pale middle. We baked cookies on the included rack at 350F and got the best results after that longer warm-up.
Who this oven suits
A couple, a single person, or anyone in a dorm or studio who wants toast and frozen pizza without heating a whole kitchen. The 6.7-pound weight means it moves to a high shelf when you need the counter, and at 14.5 inches wide it fits next to a coffee maker.
It also works for a family that mainly reheats. A 9-inch pizza is a real dinner for four when topped properly, and the keep-warm function lets you batch cook toast for a slow morning.
Who should skip it
If you regularly bake a 9×13 pan of something, the interior will not take it and no setting will change that. Move up a capacity tier rather than cramming a smaller pan onto the rack.
Skip it too if a hot exterior is a dealbreaker in a tight kitchen. The bigger convection ovens in this list run cooler to the touch for the same reason: more insulation between you and the elements.
2. Hamilton Beach Easy Reach 6-Slice – Top Rated
Hamilton Beach Easy Reach 6 Slice Countertop Toaster Oven
1400W
0.36 cu ft
18.7 in wide
150 to 450F
Two rack positions
Pros
- Highest average rating in the group at 4.5
- Handles a 12-inch pizza and a 9 by 11 inch pan
- Roll-top door stays clear of spills
- Removable door and crumb tray
Cons
- Widest footprint in the roundup at 18.7 inches
- Knob controls with no temperature readout
This was the oven our test kitchen liked most, and the 4.5 average across nearly 8000 reviews backs that up. It toasts six slices in one round, which is the practical difference between a breakfast that works and a breakfast that takes two rounds.
The roll-top door is the feature owners mention most. Instead of swinging down into your counter space, it rolls up and back, so a greasy casserole or a pie that bubbles over does not land on your worktop. Owners also praise the fact that the door unhooks completely, which lets you soak it in the sink instead of scrubbing around the hinges.
At 1400 watts it recovers heat faster than any 4-slice model we tried, and that shows on frozen pizza. The oven reached temperature and started cooking noticeably sooner, and the 12-inch pizza fit with the crust touching the elements at the edge, so we raised the rack one position.
Two rack positions mean you can brown the top of a casserole and crisp a tray of frozen fries at the same time. That is a genuine advantage over the single-rack ovens lower down this list, and it is why this one suits a family of four more than most of its competitors.
Who this oven suits
Households that cook six slices of toast on a Saturday, or that bake on two levels. The 12-inch pizza capacity is the widest in this roundup, and a 9 by 11 inch pan covers most casserole dishes.
It also suits anyone tired of cleaning a toaster oven. Removable door plus a slide-out crumb tray covers the two places crumbs actually collect.
Who should skip it
Skip it if you have a narrow counter. At 18.7 inches wide and 11.4 pounds, this is the biggest box here, and it needs clear space above and behind it.
It also has no digital readout and no temperature display, so if you like to bake to a specific number rather than to a dial setting, weigh the Cuisinart in position three instead, which pairs a wider temperature range with a larger cavity.
3. Cuisinart TOB-40 1800W – Premium Pick
Cuisinart Toaster Oven Broiler, 1800W Countertop Design, 0.5 cu. ft.
1800W
0.5 cu ft interior
16 in wide
200 to 450F
Black-on-black dial labels
Pros
- Most powerful heating element in this roundup at 1800 watts
- Largest cavity fits an 11-inch pizza
- Always Even Shade Control adjusts toast time
- Auto-slide rack and front crumb tray
Cons
- Dial labels are black on black and hard to read
- No dedicated timer so auto shut-off is not guaranteed
The Cuisinart is the one to buy if wattage is what you care about. At 1800 watts it has the strongest element in the roundup, and you feel that difference in the first minute of a cook.
Always Even Shade Control is the sleeper feature. Rather than running a fixed timer, the oven watches the toasting temperature and adjusts the time itself, so pale-thin bread and thick-cut sandwich bread both come out close to where you wanted them. That is a real advantage over the plain knob timers elsewhere on this list.
At 0.5 cubic feet, this cavity is larger than anything else we tested. After a full week of testing it handled six slices of bread, four bagel halves and an 11-inch pizza. The auto-slide rack pulls forward when you open the door, which removes the reach-in risk with a hot pan, and the front crumb tray pulls out from the face of the oven without moving the appliance.
Two failures are worth knowing before you buy. The knob labels are printed in black on a black panel, and in low light they are close to invisible, so owners tape markers next to them. And there is no independent timer, so the auto shut-off behavior depends on the control set rather than a countdown you can trust.
Who this oven suits
Bakers who work to a temperature. The 200F to 450F range, the auto-slide rack and the largest cavity in this roundup make it the most capable oven here for cookies, small cakes and a roast pan.
It also suits anyone who toasts two very different breads in the same batch. Always Even Shade Control is the only toasting assist in this group that adjusts the cook time on its own, which matters most when half the loaf is thin and half is thick.
Who should skip it
Durability is the concern. Owners report heating element failures around the three-year mark, and the element is not consumer-replaceable. That matters if you expect to hand this oven down or resell it later.
The element also runs hotter than the smaller ovens, so expect a warm top panel and keep clearance above it. If you want the capacity without the heat, the 6-slice Hamilton Beach one position up draws 400 fewer watts and has more insulation around the cavity.
4. BLACK+DECKER 5-in-1 Air Fry Oven – Best for Air Frying
BLACK+DECKER 4-Slice Air Fry Toaster Oven, 5-in-1 Countertop Oven
1150W
4-slice cavity
15.5 in wide
Air fry, bake, broil, toast, keep warm
Seven accessories
Pros
- Five cooking modes in a compact 4-slice body
- Air-fry setting works with little or no oil
- EvenToast tech targets even browning with no hot spots
- Seven accessories including a mesh basket
Cons
- Mesh basket is harder to clean than solid racks
- Air-fry mode needs the drip tray in place to manage smoke
If you want one box to do five jobs, this is the pick. Air fry, bake, broil, toast and keep warm sit on the same control panel, and the 4-slice cavity still fits a 9-inch pizza. In a kitchen with one appliance left, those modes matter more than raw capacity.
EvenToast technology is the toasting claim worth testing, and it holds up. Bread browned on both faces within a shade of the same tone across the rack, with no corner going dark, which is the single most common complaint we heard about budget ovens.
Seven accessories come in the box: a mesh air-fry tray, a bake pan, a wire rack and a combined crumb and drip tray. Owners treat the accessory count as generous for the money, which it is at this tier.
Who this oven suits
Single cooks and couples who want air-fry texture from a countertop oven without a separate air fryer taking up a second shelf. Chicken wings, frozen fries and reheated pizza all came out well in our testing.
It also suits anyone who cooks one dish at a time and wants flexibility rather than volume. Five modes cover a weeknight without a full oven.
Who should skip it
Skip it if cleaning is a sticking point. The mesh basket traps grease in its weave, and it is the piece owners complain about most often. Solid racks wipe clean; mesh does not.
The 4.1 average with an 11% one-star share sits among the weakest rating profiles in the roundup, and reviews most often trace that to the air-fry function needing the drip tray seated properly to stop smoke. Leave it out and the oven smokes.
5. Hamilton Beach Sure-Crisp 4-Slice Combo – Best for Small Kitchens
Hamilton Beach 4 Slice Countertop Air Fryer Toaster Oven Combo
1120W
11.4 liter cavity
15 in wide
200 to 450F
Toast, bake, air fry, broil
Pros
- Four cooking options in one compact appliance
- Convection circulation for even browning with little oil
- Fits a 9-inch pizza or a 3 lb chicken
- Air-fry basket
- bake pan
- broil rack and crumb tray included
Cons
- 4-slice cavity is small for family meals
- Lowest wattage of the air-fry combos so reheats run slower
This is the pick when counter space is the constraint and you still want air-fry capability. At 15 inches wide and 8.3 pounds it is one of the lighter air-fry combos we tested, and it stacks against a wall without trapping heat against a cabinet better than most.
The convection fan circulates air around the food rather than relying on two bare elements, and the difference shows on small bakes. Frozen pizza browned evenly across the whole surface instead of crisping at the edges first, which is the usual failure mode of a compact oven.
The accessory bundle is the quiet strength here. You get a metal air-fry basket, a bake pan, a broil rack and a slide-out crumb tray, and the adjustable rack moves to more than one height. Inside, a 9-inch pizza, a 3 lb chicken in an 8 by 8 inch pan or a 9 by 5 inch loaf pan all fit.
The tradeoff is wattage. At 1120 watts it has the least thermal reserve of the air-fry combos here, so reheating a full tray of leftovers takes longer than it would in the 1800W Cuisinart. If you mostly air-fry small portions, that is a fair deal.
Who this oven suits
Apartment kitchens, studio flats and any counter where 15 inches of width is the real budget. It does four jobs in that footprint, and the auto shutoff plus 30-minute timer make it safe to leave running.
It also suits anyone cooking a single small protein. The 3 lb chicken fit was the surprise of our testing for an oven this compact.
Who should skip it
A family of four eating at the same time. Four slices is four slices, and the second round of toast will sit out while the first batch cools.
If your main use is reheating large trays, the slower recovery time will show. Save a little more for one of the 1400W or 1800W models and the reheats tighten up.
6. BLACK+DECKER TO1760SS Convection 4-Slice – Best Value
BLACK+DECKER 4-Slice Toaster Oven, TO1745SSG, Even Toast, 4 Cooking Functions Bake, Broil, Toast and Keep Warm, Removable Crumb Tray, Timer
1150W
283.5 cu in
16.9 in wide
450F max
Convection bake, broil, toast, keep warm
Pros
- Natural convection circulates hot air for even results
- Over 14000 reviews averaging 4.3 stars
- Four cooking functions including convection bake
- Rack and bake pan included with a removable crumb tray
Cons
- Single rack position limits two-level cooking
- Knob controls with no temperature readout
This convection model is the value pick of the roundup. It carries the same 4.3 average as our top choice across more than 14,000 reviews, and BLACK+DECKER convection models are the name that comes up most often when people on r/Mint99 and r/BuyItForLife threads ask which budget oven to trust.
Natural convection here means the interior geometry circulates hot air rather than a fan pushing it. There is no fan noise, which is a real advantage in an open-plan flat at 6 in the morning. Cookies on the included bake pan browned evenly with no rotation needed halfway through.
Four functions cover the everyday range: convection bake, broil, toast and keep warm. The 30-minute timer carries a stay-on position for longer jobs, and the oven will not run unless the timer is set, which stops the forget-it-on-the-counter habit.
The included rack and bake pan fit the cavity exactly, which removes the common frustration of a tray that rocks or blocks the door. The removable crumb tray slides out from the front.
Who this oven suits
Anyone who wants a real baking oven rather than a toast box, at a mid-range price. The convection bake setting is the reason to pick it over a plain four-slice model, and the 4.3 rating across a huge review base is the reason to trust it.
Light sleepers also do well with it. No fan means no extra hum beyond the elements themselves.
Who should skip it
Skip it if you cook two dishes at once. A single rack position rules out a tray above and a tray below, which is the one feature that pushed the 6-slice Hamilton Beach up the list.
The 16.9-inch width is also wider than most 4-slice bodies, so measure your counter before you assume it fits where a compact oven did.
7. Elite Gourmet ETO490 9L – Best for RVs and Dorms
Elite Gourmet ETO490 9L/4-Slice Oven, 30-Min Timer, Adj. Temp, Black
800W
9 liter cavity
13.64 in wide
200 to 450F
Two rack positions
Pros
- Compact 13.64-inch footprint suits tight counters
- Just 800 watts for a low power draw
- Heats fast and handles bagels and reheats well
- Baking pan
- wire rack and removable crumb tray included
Cons
- Interior is smaller than the 4-slice label implies
- Rack sits close to the elements and gets hot
- Crumb and drip trays need frequent cleaning
Eight hundred watts is the number to notice on this one. On a normal kitchen circuit it draws less than half what a 1800W oven pulls, which is the entire argument for it in a motorhome, a dorm or a flat with older wiring and a shared breaker.
It heats quickly for its size, and it handled bagels, small bagel pizzas and reheats without any drama. The 30-minute timer and 200F to 450F adjustable temperature give you more range than the 2-slice model below, despite both being 4-slice-labelled shells.
Where owners are honest is the cavity. Despite the 4-slice label, most people toast two slices at a time because the interior is shallower than the number suggests. Plan on it as a two-to-three-slice appliance and it will not disappoint you.
The rack also sits nearer the elements than in the larger ovens, so it gets hot to grip. Grab it with a towel or a silicone mitt, and expect the crumb and drip trays to need attention more often than on a sealed 4-slice cavity.
Who this oven suits
RV and motorhome owners, dorm residents and anyone on a tight power budget. At 13.64 inches wide it fits counters that most ovens in this roundup will not, and the low draw means it can share a circuit with a kettle.
Two rack positions give it more flexibility than the single-rack 4-slice ovens, even though the interior is small.
Who should skip it
Skip it if you toast for a group. Two slices at a time is the practical limit, and there is no way to change that.
Skip it if you bake. The shallow interior puts tall items close to the upper element, and croissants or a high loaf will brown on top before the middle sets.
8. Elite Gourmet ETO236 2-Slice – Budget Pick
Elite Gourmet ETO236 Compact 2-Slice Toaster Oven, 15-Min Timer, Black
650W
2-slice cavity
13.25 in wide
200 to 450F
15-minute timer
Pros
- Weighs just 4.5 pounds
- 650 watts heats fast for a 2-slice cavity
- Bake
- broil and toast with adjustable temperature
- Non-stick back pan and wire rack included
Cons
- Lowest average in the roundup at 4.0 with a 13% one-star share
- 2-slice capacity with no convection or air-fry function
- 15-minute timer is the shortest of the roundup
This is the spend-the-least-money option and it is honest about its limits. Two slices, 650 watts, and a 15-minute timer that is the shortest in the roundup. For one person making breakfast, that is genuinely enough.
At 4.5 pounds and 6.5 inches tall, it is the easiest unit here to move, store or stow in a cupboard. It draws so little power that you can run it in a hotel room or a boat without thinking about it, and the non-stick back pan means washing up is a two-minute job.
The 4.0 average with a 13% one-star share is the weakest profile here, and the complaints are predictable: build quality at the budget end and toasting consistency across a batch of two. For a user who cares more that it works than how the last crust looks, that is a reasonable trade.
There is no convection and no air-fry function, which is why we place it last. The 200F to 450F range and three cooking modes are enough for toast, small bakes and reheats, and nothing more ambitious.
Who this oven suits
A single person, a hotel room, a caravan or a first-apartment renter who needs a second appliance for nothing more than toast and reheating. It runs a single person fine on breakfast and reheats, and it never needs the oven switched on.
It also suits anyone who wants to try the appliance without committing counter space or money to it.
Who should skip it
Two-slice capacity is the dealbreaker for most households. Forum consensus is blunt about this: buyers on cooking forums reject 2-slice budget ovens outright and point people toward heavier, better-insulated units instead.
Skip it if you want to bake or broil anything substantial. The cavity is too shallow and the 15-minute timer too short to see a real project through.
How to Choose a Sub-100 Toaster Oven
How we picked
We weighted our decisions toward toasting consistency and capacity fit, because those are the two things every buyer notices in the first ten minutes. Temperature behavior, cleaning access and counter footprint came next, then build quality and the accessory bundle as tie-breakers. Ratings and review counts broke the remaining ties.
Capacity and dish fit
Match the oven to the number of people who will eat at once. Four slices covers a couple. Six slices covers a family breakfast without two rounds. A 9-inch pizza is a real meal if you top it properly; a 12-inch pizza is a party.
Then measure the counter. The widest oven here is 18.7 inches and the narrowest is 13.25 inches, which is a five-and-a-half inch gap across the roundup. That difference decides whether the oven lives on your counter or in a cupboard.
Convection versus conventional heat
Convection means a fan pushes hot air around the cavity, which cooks faster and evens out hot spots. Conventional heating uses bare elements above and below the food. For toast, the difference barely matters. For baking a tray of cookies, it is the difference between rotating the pan halfway and not.
Check whether convection is a real fan or just marketing. The BLACK+DECKER TO1760SS and the TO1313SBD both describe natural convection airflow without a fan, which means circulating geometry rather than a motor. Silent, cheaper to run, slightly less even.
Even toasting and hot spots
Back-to-front temperature differences are the most repeated complaint about budget ovens, and the fix is the rack position. Put the rack in the middle or upper-middle rather than the lowest setting, and leave air space around the bread so heat can reach the edges.
Which toaster toasts evenly? The models with true convection fan airflow browned small batches most consistently in our testing, because circulating air evens out the radiant heat from bare elements. The natural-convection BLACK+DECKER models followed closely.
Why a toaster oven browns one side
Elements sit much closer to the top of your food than a full-size oven puts them, so infrared radiation from the upper element hits the surface before convection has equalized. Bread also has more mass on the crust side, so the crumb insulates the underside less. The result is a darker top and a paler bottom.
Two adjustments fix most of it: give the oven a full preheat before the food goes in, and move the rack down one position for thick-cut bread so the top element is further away.
Analog dials versus digital controls
Mechanical dials last. In r/BuyItForLife threads a cheap Cuisinart toaster is described as still going strong after eight years, while the most common digital failure in this category is a control board giving up after a year or two of sustained heat.
Assist functions buy you consistency rather than precision. Always Even Shade Control on the Cuisinart, which watches toasting temperature and adjusts the time itself, is the clearest example in this price tier. Pick dials for durability, and pick a toasting assist if even browning matters more to you than a printed temperature number.
Heat, clearance and foil safety
Budget ovens have thinner insulation than premium ones, so the top and sides run hot during a cook. Leave four to six inches of clearance above and behind, keep the oven off a paper towel or a wooden board, and do not tuck it into a cabinet with the door closed against the wall.
You can use foil, with rules. Keep it clear of the heating elements, the interior walls and the crumb tray, and never line a pan under the broiler. Crumbs under the elements are the most common cause of a toaster oven fire, so empty the tray weekly and wipe the floor of the cavity.
How long a budget toaster oven lasts
The average lifespan of a toaster oven runs three to five years for the cheapest tier and seven to ten years for well-made models at the top of this price range. The difference comes down to element quality, insulation thickness and whether a failed part can be replaced.
The failure point that decides the outcome is the heating element. On this roundup, the Cuisinart’s element is reported failing around the three-year mark with no consumer replacement available. Brands that sell replacement parts and publish longer warranties give you more usable years from the same purchase.
What you give up versus a 250-dollar oven
Premium ovens add a probe thermometer for real temperature verification, a convection fan with more coverage, better insulation so the exterior stays cool, and a control panel that remembers settings. Those are real improvements for frequent bakers.
For reheating leftovers, frozen pizza, toast and a tray of cookies, the sub-100 tier here performs the same core tasks. Pay up only if you bake weekly or cook large roasts, because that is where the element power and insulation start to matter.
If you want to see how the convection models on this list stack up against the wider field, our roundup of the best countertop convection ovens goes well past the hundred-dollar line.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best toaster oven for my money?
The BLACK+DECKER TO1313SBD is the strongest overall value in the sub-100 tier. It fits a 9-inch pizza or four slices of bread in a 14.5-inch-wide body, offers bake, broil, toast and keep-warm functions, and holds a 4.3 average across more than 22,000 reviews. A 30-minute timer with a stay-on option and a slide-out crumb tray finish the package.
What is the best affordable toaster oven?
Affordability has more than one answer. For the lowest sensible spend, the Elite Gourmet ETO236 handles two slices of toast with bake, broil and toast modes on a 650-watt draw. For the best balance of features and price, the BLACK+DECKER TO1313SBD gives you four slices, a 9-inch pizza and four cooking functions in a body under 15 inches wide.
What is the best rated toaster oven under 100 dollars?
By average rating, the Hamilton Beach Easy Reach 6-Slice leads this roundup at 4.5 stars from nearly 8,000 reviews, with 74 percent of owners giving it five stars. It toasts six slices at once, handles a 12-inch pizza and a 9 by 11 inch pan, and its roll-top door stays clear of spills.
Which toaster oven toasts evenly?
Evenness comes down to how heat moves through the cavity. Ovens with true convection fan airflow brown small batches most consistently because the fan evens out the radiant heat from bare elements. The natural-convection BLACK+DECKER models also perform well. Rack position matters as much as the oven: use the middle setting and leave air space around bread for an even result.
Why do toaster ovens only toast one side?
Elements sit close to the top of your food, so infrared heat hits the surface before the air temperature equalizes, while the crumb side is insulated by the loaf itself. You can correct it by giving the oven a full preheat and moving the rack down one position for thick-cut bread, which puts the upper element further from the surface.
What is the average lifespan of a toaster oven?
Expect three to five years from the cheapest tier and seven to ten years from well-made models at the top of this price range. What decides the outcome is whether the heating element can be replaced when it fails. Budget models with sealed elements that carry no consumer replacement part tend to end earlier than brands that stock spares.
Can you put foil in a toaster oven?
Yes, with care. Keep foil away from the heating elements, the interior walls and the crumb tray, and never line a pan that sits under the broiler. Foil touching a live element is the fastest route to a burned oven and a tripped breaker, and a foil-lined crumb tray blocks the airflow that clears grease.
Do budget toaster ovens have automatic shut off?
Most do, but not all in the same way. Models with a mechanical timer switch the elements off at the end of the cycle, and some add a ready bell. The Cuisinart TOB-40 has automatic shut-off behavior built into its control settings but no independent countdown timer, so check the model you buy before relying on it for an unattended cook.
Final Pick: The Best Toaster Oven Under 100 in 2026
The BLACK+DECKER TO1313SBD wins this roundup for one reason: it does the common jobs without a single weak link. Four slices and a 9-inch pizza, four cooking functions, a stay-on timer, a crumb tray that slides out from the front, and more than 22,000 reviews averaging 4.3 stars behind it. For most kitchens, that is the whole job description.
Buy the Hamilton Beach Easy Reach instead if you need six slices at once or a 12-inch pizza and have 19 inches of counter to give up. Tell us how much counter space you have and what you cook most, and we will point you at the right one of the eight.